Review: 'Forrest' resonates at Walnut
By KEVIN RIORDAN Courier-Post Staff
The Courier-Post
Publication Date 3/22/06
"FORREST: A RIOT OF DREAMS'
The cast:
Forrest: Dan Olmstead / Catherine: Emma O'Donnell / Judge: John Morrison
Ferry-Wright: Scott Greer / Truscott-Paxon: Peter Schmitz
Written by Armen Pandola.
Directed by Bill Van Horn. Scenic designer Rob Kramer.
Lighting designer Shelley Hicklin. Sound designer John Mock. Costume designer Mary Folino.
Presented by the Walnut Street Theatre Independence Studio
Edwin Forrest, after whom Philadelphia's Forrest Theater is named, was the first superstar of the young American stage. So passionately partisan were his fans that they rioted at a performance of his English rival, William Macready, in New York City in 1849.
This tumultuous cultural context is brought to boisterous life in the world premiere production of Forrest: A Riot of Dreams, at the Walnut Street Theatre's Independence Studio on 3.
South Philadelphia playwright Armen Pandola's witty, well-constructed play centers on the tempestuous relationship between Forrest (Dan Olmstead) and his British wife, Catherine Sinclair (Emma O'Donnell). Both are headstrong, egotistical and selfish, and two decades later they're in divorce court. The culture war, celebrity divorce trial and media madness at the heart of Forrest make the play abundantly topical. And Forrest also resonates because of its deeper themes: ambition, jealousy and the struggle for power in relationships between men and women.
The latter emerges as the most compelling element of the play, so much so that by the conclusion the character of Catherine has eclipsed that of Forrest. As written by Pandola and portrayed with an abundance of sly wit by O'Donnell, Catherine seems far more complex and interesting as an individual than her larger-than-life husband.
That Forrest is more concerned with the historical phenomenon of Forrest than the man himself seems intentional. But the playwright inadvertently gives the actor playing Forrest too few nuances to work with. Olmstead's presence is commanding and his theatrical chops are robust. Yet his performance seems black-and-white amid the colors (cleverly orchestrated by director Bill Van Horn) erupting around him.
The three other actors are effective in their dual roles: The volatile Scott Greer as an Irish newspaperman and Catherine's attorney and the elegantly long-faced Peter Schmitz as a British theater critic and Forrest's lawyer. But it's John Morrison's imperial, infantile divorce court judge who gets the biggest laughs in the rollicking and thought-provoking, tragi-comedy that is Forrest.